Washington medical website privacy is at the center of a significant October 8, 2026 decision from the Washington Supreme Court. In Baker v. Seattle Children’s Hospital, No. 104590-5, the court examined whether a hospital violated Washington’s Privacy Act by allegedly sharing parents’ medical-related website searches and clicks with Meta Platforms through tracking software.
The court ruled in favor of Seattle Children’s Hospital. But the decision was narrower than a general approval of online tracking: the justices held that the specific Privacy Act provision relied upon by the parents did not apply to their interactions with the hospital’s automated public website.
The ruling raises important questions about patient privacy, website technology, and the limits of Washington’s electronic communications laws.
What Happened in Baker v. Seattle Children’s Hospital?
The case began when three parents—Carly Baker, Janssen Ramos Savoie, and Amber Shavies—filed a proposed class action against Seattle Children’s Hospital.
According to their complaint, the hospital used software called Meta Pixel on its publicly accessible website.
Meta Pixel can collect information about website activity and transmit it to Meta Platforms, the company behind Facebook and Instagram.
The parents alleged that the software recorded and transmitted information about their searches, clicks, and page visits.
For example, a parent searching the hospital’s website for information about depression or another medical condition could have that activity associated with a Meta account or tracking identifier.
The plaintiffs alleged that Meta used the information, at least in part, for targeted advertising.
These were allegations accepted as true for purposes of reviewing the motion to dismiss—not factual findings following a trial.
The hospital’s website displayed a general cookie notice. However, according to the complaint, that notice did not specifically identify Meta Pixel or explain how the software collected and shared browsing data.
The parents argued that the alleged interception and recording of their website activity violated Washington law.
The trial court dismissed the lawsuit, and the Court of Appeals affirmed. The parents then sought review by the Washington Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court’s opinion is available here: Baker v. Seattle Children’s Hospital, No. 104590-5 (Wash. Oct. 8, 2026).
Washington Medical Website Privacy Under the Privacy Act
The principal statute at issue was RCW 9.73.030, part of Washington’s Privacy Act.
Washington generally requires the consent of all participants before certain private communications or conversations may be intercepted or recorded, subject to statutory exceptions.
The relevant provision, RCW 9.73.030(1)(a), applies to certain private communications transmitted by a device between two or more individuals.
That wording became the decisive issue in the case.
Why the Definition of Communication Matters
The parents argued that their medical-related searches and website interactions were private communications.
They contended that Meta Pixel intercepted or recorded those communications without adequate consent.
The hospital argued that the statute did not cover the alleged exchanges because the parents were interacting with an automated website rather than communicating with another individual.
The Supreme Court focused on the statutory requirement that a covered communication occur between at least two individuals.
Why the Washington Supreme Court Dismissed the Privacy Claim
Justice Angelis authored the majority opinion.
The majority interpreted the wording of RCW 9.73.030(1)(a) and concluded that the parents’ claims did not satisfy its requirements.
Automated Website Responses Were Decisive
When a parent entered a search term or clicked a link, the hospital’s server automatically returned the requested information.
According to the court, these exchanges involved a single individual interacting with an automated system maintained by a corporation.
The statute separately identifies individuals, corporations, partnerships, associations, and government entities.
The majority reasoned that the legislature’s use of different terms was meaningful.
Because the statute protects the specified communications between two or more individuals, the majority concluded that the parents’ automated website interactions did not qualify.
The court therefore affirmed dismissal of the Privacy Act claim.
The Court Did Not Decide Whether the Searches Were Private
This distinction is essential.
The majority did not rule that searches for children’s medical conditions are inherently public.
It did not decide whether the parents had a reasonable expectation of privacy in those searches.
Instead, the court resolved the appeal on the statutory requirement concerning who participated in the communication.
That means the decision should not be interpreted as holding that all hospital website tracking is lawful.
It establishes a limitation on the particular Washington Privacy Act claim presented in this case.
What Did Justice González Say About Medical Website Privacy?
Justice Steven González wrote a separate opinion concurring in the result.
He agreed that the parents’ claims should be dismissed because the searches were directed to an automated server rather than another individual.
However, he disagreed with aspects of the majority’s analysis.
Medical Searches Can Reveal Sensitive Information
Justice González emphasized that searching for symptoms, conditions, or medical specialists can communicate private concerns.
A parent researching a child’s health condition may reasonably expect that information to remain confidential.
The concurrence explained that the parents had sufficiently alleged private communications, even though their claim failed for a separate reason.
Justice González also noted that the effect of the hospital’s general cookie banner on the parents’ expectations of privacy was not conclusively resolved by the pleadings.
Communications With Hospital Employees Are Different
Justice González questioned any interpretation that would exclude communications simply because one participant works for a corporation.
He explained that private communications between patients and hospital employees may still be protected.
For example, a message to a medical provider, a voicemail for hospital staff, or certain internal messaging exchanges could involve two or more individuals.
Those circumstances were not before the court.
The concurrence therefore agreed with the dismissal while emphasizing that the ruling should not be extended beyond the automated public website interactions actually alleged.
Does Baker Allow Hospitals to Share Patient Information With Advertisers?
No. The decision does not establish blanket permission for hospitals to share patient information with advertising companies.
The Supreme Court decided whether the parents’ allegations stated a claim under RCW 9.73.030(1)(a).
It did not decide whether the alleged tracking violated other state or federal privacy requirements.
The parents’ complaint also included claims involving Washington’s Consumer Protection Act, health care information law, and other legal theories.
Those claims were not pursued in the Supreme Court appeal, so the justices did not determine their merits.
Other Washington Privacy Laws May Still Matter
Washington’s Uniform Health Care Information Act, chapter 70.02 RCW, regulates the handling and disclosure of health care information in covered circumstances.
The Washington Consumer Protection Act, chapter 19.86 RCW, also addresses certain unfair or deceptive business practices.
Whether either law applies to a particular website tracking practice requires a separate legal analysis.
The Baker decision does not resolve those questions.
What Does This Decision Mean for Washington Patients?
The ruling highlights a difference between the privacy expectations people may have when researching medical information and the precise legal protections provided by a particular statute.
Public Website Searches and Patient Portals Are Not Necessarily the Same
The Supreme Court limited its review to activity on Seattle Children’s publicly available website.
The parents did not pursue a claim based on alleged tracking inside the hospital’s MyChart patient portal.
As a result, the decision does not determine how the Privacy Act would apply to messages exchanged directly with doctors or other medical staff through a patient portal.
That distinction may be important when evaluating a future privacy dispute.
A Cookie Banner Does Not Answer Every Legal Question
The existence of a general cookie notice did not determine the outcome.
The court did not decide whether the parents gave legally sufficient consent to Meta Pixel tracking.
Instead, the court held that the alleged automated exchanges did not satisfy the statutory requirement involving two or more individuals.
Businesses should not assume that a cookie banner automatically satisfies every applicable privacy or consumer protection requirement.
Why This Washington Supreme Court Ruling Matters
The decision demonstrates how statutory language written for communications technology can produce difficult questions when applied to modern websites.
Today’s websites can automatically collect searches, browsing activity, device identifiers, and other information without a human employee reviewing each interaction.
That technology may reveal sensitive personal interests, including medical concerns.
Yet a privacy claim can still fail if the facts do not satisfy every element of the specific statute being invoked.
Statutory Interpretation Can Determine the Outcome
The majority focused on the legislature’s choice of words.
The court concluded that it could not rewrite the phrase “between two or more individuals” to cover the automated website interactions alleged in the complaint.
Justice González agreed with the outcome but offered a different explanation of how privacy protections should apply to communications involving corporations and their employees.
Both opinions demonstrate the importance of examining the precise statutory language and the actual nature of a communication.
Privacy Protections Depend on the Particular Facts
A search on a public website, a direct email to a medical provider, and a message sent through a patient portal are not necessarily treated identically under Washington law.
The identity of the participants, the technology used, the information transmitted, and the legal claim asserted may all matter.
People facing disputes involving confidential communications may also find it helpful to understand related but distinct legal protections, including Washington ER 502 and attorney-client privilege. Privilege rules are different from the Privacy Act, but both illustrate the importance of identifying the legal protection that applies to a particular communication.
What Should Someone Do if Their Private Information Was Shared?
Anyone concerned about the disclosure of sensitive information should begin by identifying what information may have been collected, which organization collected it, and whether it was disclosed to a third party.
The next step is determining which laws potentially apply.
The Baker decision shows why legal analysis should not stop at the conclusion that information was sensitive or that a tracking tool was involved.
A viable claim must satisfy the requirements of the law under which it is brought.
Different rules may apply to medical records, communications with health care providers, online advertising practices, and other forms of data collection.
Contact Blanford Law
The Washington Supreme Court’s decision in Baker v. Seattle Children’s Hospital underscores the importance of understanding how statutory protections apply to modern technology.
Whether a legal issue involves privacy, constitutional protections, or another Washington legal dispute, careful examination of the governing law is essential.
Contact Blanford Law today at ken@blanfordlaw.com or 253-720-9304 for guidance on your legal matter.

Additional Resources
Related Blanford Law Articles
1. Washington ER 502 Privilege: Attorney-Client & Work Product
Explains the separate legal rules protecting attorney-client communications and work product, including when disclosure may affect those protections.
URL: https://blanfordlaw.com/washington-er-502-attorney-client-privilege/
2. Right to Counsel Waiver Washington: State v. Thompson Explained
Examines how Washington courts evaluate the waiver of constitutional rights and the importance of a clear factual record.
URL: https://blanfordlaw.com/right-to-counsel-waiver-washington/
3. Allstate v. Batacan UIM Dispute: Washington Coverage & Liability Limits
Discusses a Washington insurance dispute that included Consumer Protection Act allegations, illustrating how statutory requirements can determine the outcome of a civil claim.
URL: https://blanfordlaw.com/allstate-v-batacan-uim-dispute/
The two additional orphaned-content links must be selected from the current unused pool before publication. They have not been fabricated or replaced with links whose unused status cannot be established.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about Washington law and is not legal advice. The outcome of any legal matter depends on its facts and applicable law.