The United States is witnessing a significant and troubling trend in its legal system: a mass departure of prosecutors from their roles, leading to unprecedented vacancy rates in prosecution offices nationwide. Adam Gershowitz, a research professor at William & Mary Law School, sheds light on this issue, revealing how it’s not just a crisis for the legal system but particularly detrimental for criminal defendants.
Unpacking the Prosecution Crisis
Gershowitz’s research, highlighted in both Slate and an SSRN paper, points to alarmingly high vacancy rates across the board. Cities like Houston and Los Angeles report rates over 15%, with Fort Lauderdale, Florida, and Detroit experiencing even higher shortages. The crisis peaks in places like Alameda, California, and Miami, with vacancy rates reaching 25% and 33%, respectively. This scarcity of prosecutors signifies a looming crisis in the legal profession, with far-reaching implications for justice and fairness.
Root Causes of the Exodus
The departure of legal professionals from prosecution roles can be attributed to several key factors:
- The “George Floyd Effect”: The tragic death of George Floyd has reshaped law students’ career preferences, with many now opting for roles as public defenders rather than prosecutors.
- Pandemic-induced Backlogs: The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly increased caseloads, exacerbating the workload on existing staff.
- Economic Disincentives: The combination of low entry-level salaries (around $70,000), lack of remote work options, and demanding discovery obligations has made the role of a prosecutor less appealing.
- Internal Disagreements: The election of progressive prosecutors has sometimes led to policy disagreements, contributing to staff turnover.
- Educational Trends: A decrease in law school graduates and a lower bar passage rate during the pandemic have reduced the pool of potential applicants.
The Defendant’s Dilemma
This prosecutorial exodus spells bad news for criminal defendants. Overburdened prosecutors are more likely to delay identifying wrongful accusations, have less capacity to screen cases for diversion programs like drug courts, and struggle to allocate time to assess plea deals fairly. This inefficiency threatens the core of justice, potentially resulting in unjust outcomes for the accused.
A Stark Contrast
The decline in interest in prosecutorial roles is stark, as illustrated by the application numbers. For instance, Miami-Dade County, Florida, saw a dramatic decrease from 2,000 applicants in 1991 to just 300 in 2023. Similarly, Colorado’s 17th Judicial District’s call for ten positions attracted a mere one or two applications, leaving the positions unfilled for an extended period.
A Call for Action
The ongoing crisis in prosecution offices underscores a pressing challenge for the legal framework, demanding a reevaluation of how prosecutorial roles are perceived and supported. It’s imperative to address the factors deterring potential candidates from these crucial roles to ensure the legal system can deliver justice effectively and equitably.
Areas of Practice: DUI & Alcohol Offences, Criminal Defense, Personal Injury, Domestic Violence and Traffic Infractions.
We service Roslyn and Tacoma, Washington State and surrounding areas.
Review our client resources here
Contact us anytime for your urgent legal needs.
About Blanford Law:
We are no-nonsense, relentless, fair, and honest. We are great listeners instead of fast talkers, that is just who we are. More than 20 years ago, Ken began practicing law with a deeply-seeded belief that every person has the right to the best legal representation available. He built his law firm on that belief. Another belief that he strongly adheres to is his fundamental belief that clients deserve respect, with no assumptions or preconceived notions. If you or someone you know is accused of a crime or injured as a result of the negligence of another, please have them call us at 253-720-9304 or email us info@blanfordlaw.com
